 | ||
| Year | All-Stars (Pos.) | |
| ||
| 2016 | Carlos Beltran, OF; Dellin Betances, P; Andrew Miller, P | |
| ||
| 2015 | Brett Gardner, OF; Mark Teixeira, 1B; Dellin Betances, P | |
| ||
| 2014 | Derek Jeter, SS*; Masahiro Tanaka, P; Dellin Betances, P | |
| ||
| 2013 | Robinson Cano, 2B*; Mariano Rivera, P | |
| ||
| 2012 | Robinson Cano, 2B*; Derek Jeter, SS*; Curtis Granderson, OF*; CC Sabathia, P | |
| ||
| 2011 | Robinson Cano, 2B*; Derek Jeter, SS*; Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Curtis Granderson, OF*; Russell Martin, C; P; Mariano Rivera, P; David Robertson, P; CC Sabathia, P | |
| ||
| 2010 | Robinson Cano, 2B*; Derek Jeter, SS*; Alex Rodriguez, 3B; Nick Swisher, OF; Phil Hughes, P; Andy Pettitte, P; Mariano Rivera, P; CC Sabathia, P | |
| ||
| 2009 | Mark Teixeira, 1B*; Derek Jeter, SS*; Mariano Rivera, P | |
| ||
| 2008 | Derek Jeter, SS*; Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Mariano Rivera, P | |
| ||
| 2007 | Derek Jeter, SS*; Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Jorge Posada, C | |
| ||
| 2006 | Derek Jeter, SS*; Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Robinson Cano, 2B; Mariano Rivera, P | |
| ||
| 2005 | Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Mariano Rivera, P; Gary Sheffield, OF | |
| ||
| 2004 | Jason Giambi, 1B*; Tom Gordon, P; Derek Jeter, SS*; Hideki Matsui, OF; Mariano Rivera, P; Alex Rodriguez, 3B*; Gary Sheffield, OF; Javier Vazquez, P | |
| ||
| 2003 | Roger Clemens, P; Jason Giambi, 1B; Hideki Matsui*, OF; Jorge Posada*, C; Alfonso Soriano*, 2B | |
| ||
| 2002 | Jason Giambi*, 1B; Derek Jeter, SS; Jorge Posada*; C, Mariano Rivera, P; Alfonso Soriano*, 2B; Robin Ventura, 3B; Joe Torre, Mgr | |
| ||
| 2001 | Roger Clemens**, P; Derek Jeter, SS; Pettitte, P; Jorge Posada, C; Mike Stanton, P; Bernie Williams, OF; Joe Torre, Mgr | |
| ||
| 2000 | Derek Jeter**, SS; Jorge Posada, C; Mariano Rivera, P; Bernie Williams*, OF; Joe Torre, Mgr | |
| ||
| 1999 | David Cone, P; Derek Jeter, SS; Mariano Rivera, P; Bernie Williams, OF; Joe Torre, Mgr | |
| ||
| 1998 | Scott Brosius, 3B; Derek Jeter, SS; Paul O'Neill, OF; David Wells*, P; Bernie Williams, OF | |
| ||
| 1997 | David Cone, P; Tino Martinez*, 1B; Paul O'Neill**, OF; Mariano Rivera, P; Bernie Williams, OF; Joe Torre, Mgr | |
| ||
| 1996 | Wade Boggs*, 3B; Andy Pettitte, P; John Wetteland, P | |
| ||
| 1995 | Wade Boggs*, 3B; Paul O'Neill, OF; Mike Stanley, C; Buck Showalter, Mgr | |
| ||
| 1994 | Wade Boggs*, 3B; Jimmy Key*, P; Paul O'Neill, OF | |
| ||
| 1993 | Wade Boggs*, 3B; Jimmy Key, P | |
| ||
| 1992 | Roberto Kelly, OF | |
| ||
| 1991 | Scott Sanderson, P | |
| ||
| 1990 | Steve Sax, 2B | |
| ||
| 1989 | Don Mattingly, 1B; Steve Sax, 2B | |
| ||
| 1988 | Rickey Henderson*, OF; Don Mattingly, 1B; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1987 | Rickey Henderson*, OF; Don Mattingly*, 1B; Willie Randolph*, 2B; Dave Righetti, P; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1986 | Rickey Henderson*, OF; Don Mattingly, 1B; Dave Righetti, P; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1985 | Rickey Henderson*, OF; Don Mattingly, 1B; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1984 | Phil Niekro, P; Don Mattingly, 1B; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1983 | Ron Guidry, P; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1982 | Rich "Goose" Gossage, P; Ron Guidry, P; Dave Winfield, OF | |
| ||
| 1981 | Ron Davis, P; Bucky Dent*, SS; Rich "Goose" Gossage, P; Reggie Jackson*, OF; Willie Randolph*, 2B; Dave Winfield*, OF | |
| ||
| 1980 | Bucky Dent*, SS; Rich "Goose" Gossage, P; Reggie Jackson*, OF; Tommy John, P; Graig Nettles*, 3B; Willie Randolph*, 2B | |
| ||
| 1979 | Ron Guidry, P; Reggie Jackson, OF; Tommy John, P; Graig Nettles, 3B | |
| ||
| 1978 | Rich "Goose" Gossage, P; Ron Guidry, P; Reggie Jackson*, OF; Graig Nettles, 3B | |
| ||
| 1977 | Reggie Jackson*, OF; Sparky Lyle, P; Thurman Munson, C; Graig Nettles, 3B; Willie Randolph*, 2B | |
| ||
| 1976 | Chris Chambliss, 1B; Catfish Hunter, P; Sparky Lyle, P; Thurman Munson*, C; Willie Randolph, 2B; Mickey Rivers, OF | |
| ||
| 1975 | Bobby Bonds*, OF; Catfish Hunter, P; Thurman Munson*, C; Graig Nettles*, 3B | |
| ||
| 1974 | Thurman Munson*, C; Bobby Murcer*, OF | |
| ||
| 1973 | Sparky Lyle, P; Thurman Munson, C; Bobby Murcer*, OF | |
| ||
| 1972 | Bobby Murcer*, OF | |
| ||
| 1971 | Thurman Munson, C; Bobby Murcer*, OF | |
| ||
| 1970 | Fritz Peterson, P; Mel Stottlemyre, P; Roy White, OF | |
| ||
| 1969 | Mel Stottlemyre**, P; Roy White, OF | |
| ||
| 1968 | Mickey Mantle, 1B; Mel Stottlemyre, P | |
| ||
| 1967 | Al Downing, P; Mickey Mantle, 1B | |
| ||
| 1966 | Bobby Richardson, 2B; Mel Stottlemyre, P | |
| ||
| 1965 | Elston Howard, C; Mickey Mantle, OF; Joe Pepitone, 1B; Bobby Richardson, 2B; Mel Stottlemyre, P | |
| ||
| 1964 | Whitey Ford, P; Elston Howard*, C; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Joe Pepitone, 1B; Bobby Richardson, 2B | |
| ||
| 1963 | Jim Bouton, P; Elston Howard, C; Mickey Mantle, OF; Joe Pepitone*, 1B; Bobby Richardson, 2B; Tom Tresh, OF | |
| ||
| 1962 | Yogi Berra##, C; Elston Howard###, C; Mickey Mantle*###, OF; Roger Maris*###, OF; Bobby Richardson###, 2B; Ralph Terry###, P; Tom Tresh###, SS | |
| ||
| 1961 | Luis Arroyo##, P; Yogi Berra###, OF; Whitey Ford###, P; Elston Howard###, C; Tony Kubek*###, SS; Mickey Mantle*###, OF; Roger Maris*###, OF; Bill Skowron##, 1B | |
| ||
| 1960 | Yogi Berra*###, C; Jim Coates###, P; Whitey Ford**###, P; Elston Howard###, C; Mickey Mantle*###, OF; Roger Maris*###, OF; Bill Skowron*###, 1B | |
| ||
| 1959 | Yogi Berra###, C; Ryne Duren###, P; Whitey Ford#, P; Mickey Mantle###, OF; Gil McDougald#, SS; Bobby Richardson###, 2B; Bill Skowron*#, 1B; Elston Howard##, C; Tony Kubek##, SS | |
| ||
| 1958 | Yogi Berra, C; Ryne Duren, P; Whitey Ford, P; Elston Howard, C; Tony Kubek, inf; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Gil McDougald, 2B; Bill Skowron, 1B; Bob Turley**, P | |
| ||
| 1957 | Yogi Berra*, C; Bob Grim, P; Elston Howard, C; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Gil McDougald, SS; Bobby Richardson, 2B; Bobby Shantz, P; Bill Skowron, 1B | |
| ||
| 1956 | Yogi Berra*, C; Whitey Ford, P; Johnny Kucks, P; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Billy Martin, 2B; Gil McDougald, SS | |
| ||
| 1955 | Yogi Berra*, C; Whitey Ford, P; Mickey Mantle, OF; Bob Turley, P | |
| ||
| 1954 | Hank Bauer, OF; Yogi Berra*, C; Whitey Ford**, P; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Irv Noren, OF; Allie Reynolds, P | |
| ||
| 1953 | Hank Bauer*, OF; Yogi Berra*, C; Mickey Mantle*, OF; Johnny Mize, 1B; Allie Reynolds, P; Phil Rizzuto, SS; Johnny Sain, P | |
| ||
| 1952 | Hank Bauer*, OF; Yogi Berra*, C; Mickey Mantle, OF; Vic Raschi**, P; Allie Reynolds, P; Phil Rizzuto, SS; Gil McDougald, 2B | |
| ||
| 1951 | Yogi Berra*, C; Joe Dimaggio, OF; Ed Lopat, P; Phil Rizzuto, SS | |
| ||
| 1950 | Yogi Berra*, C; Tommy Byrne, P; Coleman, 2B; Joe Dimaggio, OF; Tommy Henrich, 1B; Vic Raschi**, P. Allie Reynolds, P; Phil Rizzuto*, SS | |
| ||
| 1949 | Yogi Berra, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Tommy Henrich, OF; Vic Raschi, P; Allie Reynolds, P | |
| ||
| 1948 | Yogi Berra, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Tommy Henrich**, OF; George McQuinn, 1B; Joe Page, P; Vic Raschi, P | |
| ||
| 1947 | Spud Chandler, P; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Tommy Henrich, OF; Billy Johnson, 3B; George McQuinn*, 1B; Joe Page, P; Aaron Robinson, C; Spec Shea, P; Charlie Keller, OF | |
| ||
| 1946 | Spud Chandler, P; Bill Dickey, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Joe Gordon, 2B; Charlie Keller*, OF; Snuffy Stirnweiss, 3B | |
| ||
| 1945 | No game due to World War II travel restrictions | |
| ||
| 1944 | Hank Borowy**, P; Rollie Hemsley, C; Joe Page, P | |
| ||
| 1943 | Tiny Bonhom, P; Spud Chandler, P; Bill Dickey, C; Joe Gordon, 2B; Charlie Keller, OF; Johnny Lindell, OF | |
| ||
| 1942 | Tiny Bonhom, P; Spud Chandler**, P; Bill Dickey, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Joe Gordon*, 2B; Henrich*, OF; Phil Rizzuto, SS; Buddy Rosar, C; Red Ruffing, P | |
| ||
| 1941 | Bill Dickey*, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Joe Gordon, 2B; Charlie Keller, OF; Red Ruffing, P; Marius Russo, P | |
| ||
| 1940 | Bill Dickey*, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Joe Gordon*, 2B; Charlie Keller*, OF; Monte Pearson, P; Red Rolfe, 3B; Red Ruffing**, P | |
| ||
| 1939 | Frankie Crosetti, SS; Bill Dickey*, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Lefty Gomez, P; Joe Gordon*, 2B; Johnny Murphy, P; Red Rolfe, 3B; Red Ruffing, P; George Selkirk*, OF | |
| ||
| 1938 | Bill Dickey*, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Lou Gehrig, 1B; Lefty Gomez**, P; Red Rolfe, 3B; Red Ruffing, P | |
| ||
| 1937 | Bill Dickey*, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Lou Gehrig, 1B; Lefty Gomez**, P; Johnny Murphy, P; Red Rolfe*, 3B | |
| ||
| 1936 | Frankie Crosetti, SS; Bill Dickey, C; Joe Dimaggio*, OF; Lou Gehrig*, 1B; Lefty Gomez, P; Monte Pearson, P; George Selkirk, OF | |
| ||
| 1935 | Ben Chapman, OF; Lou Gehrig*, 1B; Lefty Gomez**, P | |
| ||
| 1934 | Ben Chapman, OF; Bill Dickey*, C; Lou Gehrig*, 1B; Lefty Gomez**, P; Red Ruffing, P; Babe Ruth*, OF | |
| ||
| 1933 | Ben Chapman*, OF; Bill Dickey, C; Lou Gehrig*, 1B;Lefty Gomez**, P; Tony Lazzeri, 2B; Babe Ruth*, OF | |
| ||
| * Selected as starter || ** Started, but not elected # On team for first game only || ## On team for second game only || ### On team for both games |
||
